论学校教育与学生自主性发展—与西方学者汉德等人对话

熊川武; 江玲

论学校教育与学生自主性发展—与西方学者汉德等人对话

熊川武,
江玲

华东师范大学教育学系, 上海 200062

Haworth L.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:55.
Adams H.Justice for Children:Autonomy Development and the State.New York:State University of New York Press, 2008:12.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):541.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):537.
M.Hand.Education for autonomy:a rejoinder to Aviram and Assor.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1)：128.
叶奕乾等编：《个性心理学》, 上海：华东师范大学出版社, 1993年, 第474页。
Haworth L.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:189.
R.F.Dearden.Autonomy and Education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:454.
M.Hand.Education for autonomy:a rejoinder to Aviram and Assor.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1)：128.
熊川武：《反思性教学》, 上海：华东师范大学出版社, 1999年, 第94页。
中央教育科学研究所比较教育研究室编译：《简明国际教育百科全书.教学(下)》, 北京：教育科学出版社, 1990年, 第350页。
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):537.
G.T.Page, J.B.Thomas, A.R.Marshall.International Dictionary of Education.London:Kogan Page, 1977:16.
Haworth L.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:184.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):540.
C.M.Stone.Autonomy, emotions and desires:some problems concerning R.F.Dearden’s account of autonomy.Journal of Philosophy of Education, 1990, 24(2):271-283.
L.Haworth.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:11.
R.F.Dearden.Autonom and education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:454-455.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):539.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):541.
L.Haworth.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:183.
[美]凯根J, 赫斯顿A C, 墨森P H, 等著：《儿童发展和个性》, 缪小春, 刘金花, 武进之, 等译, 上海：上海教育出版社, 1990年, 第508页。
顾明远：《教育大词典》(增订合编本上), 上海：上海教育出版社, 1997年, 第765页。
R.F.Dearden.Autonomy and Education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:448.
H.Adams.Justice forChildren:Autonomy Development and the State.New York:State University of New York Press, 2008:12.
Adams H.Justice for Children:Autonomy Development and the State.New York:State University of New York Press, 2008:17.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):539.
A.Aviram, A.Assor.In defence of personal autonomy as a fundamental educational aim in liberal democracies:a response to Hand.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1):114.
Adams H.Justice for Children:Autonomy Development and the State.New York:State University of New York Press, 2008:P27.
H.Adams.Justice forChildren:Autonomy Development and the State.New York:State University of New York Press, 2008:17.
A.Aviram, A.Assor.In defence of personal autonomy as a fundamental educational aim in liberal democracies:a response to Hand.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1):112.
R.F.Dearden.Autonomy and Education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:448-449.
D.Boud.Developing Student Autonomy in Learning.London:Kogan Page, 1981：23.
Haworth L.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:187.
R.F.Dearden.Autonom and education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:461.
A.Aviram, A.Assor.In defence of personal autonomy as a fundamental educational aim in liberal democracies:a response to Hand.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1):112.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):541.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):539.
顾明远：《教育大词典》(增订合编本上), 上海：上海教育出版社, 1997年, 第765页。
M.Hand.Education for autonomy:a rejoinder to Aviram and Assor.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1)：128.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):538.
D.C.McClelland, Robert I.Watson Jr.Power motivation and risk-taking behavior.Journal of Personality, 1973, 41(1):128-134.
R.F.Dearden.Autonom and education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:449.
S.E.Cuypers.Autonomy in R.S.Peter’s educational theory.Journal of Philosophy of Education, 2010, 13(10):189-207.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):537.
M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):539.
计量
- 文章访问数: 211
- HTML全文浏览量: 186
- PDF下载量: 0
- 被引次数: 0
出版历程
- 刊出日期: 2013-12-20

Schooling and the Development of Students' Autonomy

摘要

摘要: 西方学者汉德相继发表的“反对把自主性作为教育目的”等文章, 忽略了学生自主性的特殊性与学校教育目的的特定功能, 用社会成员自主性和社会情境这些与“教育目的”几乎没有对应关系的“前提”推导出“自主性不能成为教育目的”的结论, 存在概念不清与逻辑混乱的问题。对这些观点进行质疑, 旨在强化学校教育目的应与时俱进, 引领学校在发展学生自主性上大做文章。
- 学校教育 /
- 学生 /
- 自主性 /
- 发展
注释:

1) Haworth L.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:55.

2) Adams H.Justice for Children:Autonomy Development and the State.New York:State University of New York Press, 2008:12.

3) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):541.

4) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):537.

5) M.Hand.Education for autonomy:a rejoinder to Aviram and Assor.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1)：128.

6) 叶奕乾等编：《个性心理学》, 上海：华东师范大学出版社, 1993年, 第474页。

7) Haworth L.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:189.

8) R.F.Dearden.Autonomy and Education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:454.

9) M.Hand.Education for autonomy:a rejoinder to Aviram and Assor.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1)：128.

10) 熊川武：《反思性教学》, 上海：华东师范大学出版社, 1999年, 第94页。

11) 中央教育科学研究所比较教育研究室编译：《简明国际教育百科全书.教学(下)》, 北京：教育科学出版社, 1990年, 第350页。

12) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):537.

13) G.T.Page, J.B.Thomas, A.R.Marshall.International Dictionary of Education.London:Kogan Page, 1977:16.

14) Haworth L.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:184.

15) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):540.

16) C.M.Stone.Autonomy, emotions and desires:some problems concerning R.F.Dearden’s account of autonomy.Journal of Philosophy of Education, 1990, 24(2):271-283.

17) L.Haworth.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:11.

18) R.F.Dearden.Autonom and education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:454-455.

19) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):539.

20) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):541.

21) L.Haworth.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:183.

22) [美]凯根J, 赫斯顿A C, 墨森P H, 等著：《儿童发展和个性》, 缪小春, 刘金花, 武进之, 等译, 上海：上海教育出版社, 1990年, 第508页。

23) 顾明远：《教育大词典》(增订合编本上), 上海：上海教育出版社, 1997年, 第765页。

24) R.F.Dearden.Autonomy and Education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:448.

25) H.Adams.Justice forChildren:Autonomy Development and the State.New York:State University of New York Press, 2008:12.

26) Adams H.Justice for Children:Autonomy Development and the State.New York:State University of New York Press, 2008:17.

27) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):539.

28) A.Aviram, A.Assor.In defence of personal autonomy as a fundamental educational aim in liberal democracies:a response to Hand.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1):114.

29) Adams H.Justice for Children:Autonomy Development and the State.New York:State University of New York Press, 2008:P27.

30) H.Adams.Justice forChildren:Autonomy Development and the State.New York:State University of New York Press, 2008:17.

31) A.Aviram, A.Assor.In defence of personal autonomy as a fundamental educational aim in liberal democracies:a response to Hand.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1):112.

32) R.F.Dearden.Autonomy and Education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:448-449.

33) D.Boud.Developing Student Autonomy in Learning.London:Kogan Page, 1981：23.

34) Haworth L.Autonomy:An Essay in Philosophy Psychology and Ethics.New Heaven:Yale University Press, 1986:187.

35) R.F.Dearden.Autonom and education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:461.

36) A.Aviram, A.Assor.In defence of personal autonomy as a fundamental educational aim in liberal democracies:a response to Hand.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1):112.

37) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):541.

38) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):539.

39) 顾明远：《教育大词典》(增订合编本上), 上海：上海教育出版社, 1997年, 第765页。

40) M.Hand.Education for autonomy:a rejoinder to Aviram and Assor.Oxford Review of Education, 2010, 36(1)：128.

41) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):538.

42) D.C.McClelland, Robert I.Watson Jr.Power motivation and risk-taking behavior.Journal of Personality, 1973, 41(1):128-134.

43) R.F.Dearden.Autonom and education.R.F.Dearden, P.H.Hirst, R.S.Peters.Education and the Development of Reason.New York:Routlege, 2010:449.

44) S.E.Cuypers.Autonomy in R.S.Peter’s educational theory.Journal of Philosophy of Education, 2010, 13(10):189-207.

45) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):537.

46) M.Hand.Against autonomy as an educational aim.Oxford Review of Education, 2006, 32(4):539.