Construction of Modern Apprenticeship in Higher Vocational Colleges: the System Bottleneck and Strategies
-
摘要: 实施现代学徒制不仅是高等职业教育主动服务当前经济社会发展的必然要求,也是推动职业教育体系与产业经济体系互动、扩展技术技能人才成长的有效途径,还是推进现代职业教育体系建设的重要战略抉择。现代学徒制在西方国家已经取得了较好的人才培养效果,已被实践证明是一种符合职业教育规律的人才培养模式。通过阐明参与到高职院校现代学徒制构建的相关主体及其利益诉求,本文借助经济社会学“社会建构”这一理论视角,分析了高职院校现代学徒制构建所面临的制度障碍及其消极影响;并针对当下高职院校构建与实践现代学徒制面临的制度困境,通过深入剖析某高职院校现代学徒制实践案例,提出了五大机制制度,为作为基层创新与实践主体的高职院校指出了在当前制度环境下现代学徒制的实践路径。Abstract: The implementation of modern apprenticeship is not only inevitable for higher vocational education to better serve the current economic and social development, but also an efficient approach to promoting the interaction between vocational education system and industrial economic system, as well as the development of skilled talents. In addition, it is important for the construction of modern vocational education system. In western countries, modern apprenticeship, which has made great contribution to the development of skilled talents, proves to be an effective training mode in vocational education. From the perspective of social construction and by identifying the stakeholders and their interest concerns, this paper analyzes the institutional obstacles and their negative influence on the construction of modern apprentice system. For example, the lack of a credible commitment between enterprises and the apprentice undermines enterprises' positivity; the lack of the protection system of apprentice rights and interests tends to cause apprentice alienation; the absence of industry education function leads to the high cost of transactions between schools and enterprises; the lack of the protection system of labor safety impedes the identity of enterprise masters; the lack of the national curriculum framework gets the quality of apprenticeship training out of control.Based on the above analysis, the authors discuss the challenges facing higher vocational colleges in their construction and practice of modern apprenticeship, and then put forward five mechanisms by analyzing some cases of modern apprentice system in higher vocational colleges. The five mechanisms are:a) building an interest-driven mechanism by integrating the interests of all parties; b) setting up a mechanism of communication consultation through a joint management platform; c) constructing a cooperation mechanism between masters and teachers; d) constructing a curriculum development mechanism through collaborative curriculum development; e) constructing a quality guarantee mechanism by establishing evaluation system. In conclusion, the paper argues how higher vocational colleges could promote modern apprenticeship under the current institutional environment through their innovative practices.
-
Key words:
- higher vocational colleges /
- modern apprenticeship /
- system bottleneck /
- strategies
-
表 1 高职院校现代学徒制构建参与主体一览表
参与主体 主要利益诉求 企业 获得优质的人力资源,实现技能替代与传承,增强企业竞争力。 高职院校 节约办学成本,提高人才质量,获得优质办学资源。 学徒 提高技术技能,有较好的工资待遇与良好的生涯发展前景。 政府 促进经济发展,保障社会稳定。 企业师傅 获得经济报酬和企业或行业内的地位与声望。 行业协会 确保行业内技能传承的秩序与行业竞争力的提升。 -
[1] 王星.(2014).技能形成的社会建构--中国工厂师徒制变迁历程的社会学分析.北京:社会科学文献出版社. [2] 周琳, 梁宁森.(2016).现代学徒制建构的实践症结及对策探析.中国高教研究, (1), 103-106. http://www.cnki.com.cn/Article/CJFDTOTAL-ZGGJ201601028.htm [3] 冉云芳.(2015).东部企业缘何跑到西部职校寻合作.取自:http://www.jyb.cn/zyjy/sjts/201504/t20150416_619221.html. [4] 北大、清华关注新生代农民工调查组.(2011).西进--富士康内迁调查报告.取自:http://wenku.baidu.com/link?url=x4nF2vFTSbKmYmoeJdGoSNIxMA0P8K6gV1zQqZo4RiRqPRCHydXEh6lEsgN9mmsFwTaHJSaaeaZEoahVNsLwSdD_4DMpGAK5M-bc1AGqsFe. [5] 关晶, 石伟平.(2014).现代学徒制之"现代性"辨析.教育研究, (10), 97-102. http://www.cnki.com.cn/Article/CJFDTOTAL-ZJLT201501023.htm [6] 关晶.(2010).西方学徒制研究.上海:华东师范大学博士学位论文. [7] 耿洁.(2011).职业教育校企合作体制机制研究.天津:天津大学博士学位论文. [8] 王婀娜, 姜大源.(2012).德国企业教师资质条例(2009年1月21日).中国职业技术教育, (10), 89-91. [9] 张利庠, 杨希.(2008).企业参与校企合作职业教育影响因素的实证研究.中国职业技术教育, (33), 56-59.